Blog

We keep you up to date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.

Tax Deductions and Donor-Advised Funds: Do You Really Control Your Money?

For business owners in Rancho Cucamonga, Upland, and Ontario, navigating a high-income year often sparks a search for robust tax deductions. Whether you operate a successful medical practice, manage a fleet of commercial trucks along the I-10 corridor, or just closed a highly profitable real estate investment, lowering your tax burden is always a priority.

Enter the donor-advised fund (DAF). For years, financial experts have championed DAFs as an incredibly flexible way to support charitable causes while maximizing immediate tax benefits. You can contribute appreciated assets, claim a deduction right away, completely avoid capital gains taxes, and take your time deciding which charities will eventually receive the funds.

However, a recent legal dispute involving a massive $21 million fund is bringing a crucial detail to light: once your money enters that fund, it no longer legally belongs to you.

The Mechanics of a DAF for Southern California Businesses

A donor-advised fund is essentially a charitable giving account sponsored by a public charity. The process is straightforward but powerful for tax planning.

First, you contribute assets. This could be cash, but for real estate brokers or logistics company owners, it often includes appreciated stock or real property. Second, you receive a tax deduction in the year of the contribution. Third, those assets are invested and grow completely tax-free. Finally, you get to recommend which charities receive grants over time.

These accounts have skyrocketed in popularity because they allow taxpayers to separate the timing of their tax deduction from the timing of their actual charitable gifts. For example, a local dentist having an exceptionally profitable year might bunch several years' worth of charitable giving into a single tax year to offset their high income. Nationwide, donor-advised funds held more than $326 billion in assets as of 2024.

Small plants representing the long-term financial growth of donor advised funds

The Lawsuit: Advised, Not Controlled

The current legal spotlight focuses on a $21 million donor-advised fund managed by WaterStone, a charitable foundation based in Colorado.

Court filings detail a dispute involving Philip Peterson, who stepped in as the successor advisor for a fund originally set up by his late father. Peterson claims the sponsoring charity effectively cut off communication and flatly refused to entertain his recommendations for distributing the money. In response, WaterStone points to the original donor agreement, asserting that they hold full legal discretion over grant decisions and have no legal obligation to follow the recommendations of any donor or successor.

Southern California Small Business Owners: Let’s Optimize Your Tax Strategy
Are you a small business owner in Inland Empire, Los Angeles, or Orange County? Let’s discuss tailored tax strategies designed specifically for small businesses in Southern California. Book your free consultation with a licensed CPA today.
Book Your Appointment

This lawsuit serves as a wake-up call regarding a core feature of a DAF: the contribution is irrevocable. Legal ownership immediately transfers to the sponsoring charity. While most sponsors routinely follow a donor's wishes, those requests are strictly advisory. You are making suggestions, not issuing commands.

Protecting Your Legacy and Generational Giving

This legal friction is particularly relevant if you are planning to use a DAF to build a multi-generational legacy. Many Inland Empire family business owners want their children or grandchildren to continue managing the family's philanthropic efforts after they pass.

While many sponsoring organizations welcome successor advisors, policies vary drastically from one institution to the next. Some charities allow multiple generations to maintain advisory privileges indefinitely, while others enforce strict limits or eventually terminate the fund entirely, absorbing the assets into their general charitable pool.

Key Questions to Ask Before Funding

If you are thinking about utilizing this strategy, you need to look past the immediate tax deduction. Ask the sponsoring organization a few pointed questions before committing your hard-earned business capital:

  • Can I formally name successor advisors?
  • How many generations are permitted to hold advisory privileges?
  • Can the fund be transferred to a different sponsor later?
  • Under what exact circumstances would a grant recommendation be denied?
  • What happens to the remaining funds if a successor advisor is not named?

Aligning Charitable Planning with Your Business Goals

Despite the headlines surrounding the Colorado lawsuit, donor-advised funds remain highly effective tools for managing wealth and lowering tax liabilities. They are still an excellent way to handle complex charitable planning strategies, especially for high-net-worth individuals and business owners trying to navigate California's demanding tax landscape.

The key takeaway is that understanding the operational rules of your chosen charity is just as critical as calculating the upfront tax savings. If you need help evaluating whether a donor-advised fund fits into your long-term tax strategy, reach out to our firm to schedule a consultation.

Southern California Small Business Owners: Let’s Optimize Your Tax Strategy
Are you a small business owner in Inland Empire, Los Angeles, or Orange County? Let’s discuss tailored tax strategies designed specifically for small businesses in Southern California. Book your free consultation with a licensed CPA today.
Book Your Appointment
Share this article...

Sign up for our newsletter.

Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

We care about the protection of your data.